24-Hour Crisis Hotline: (877)SAFEGBC or (877)723-3422 Mental Health & Substance Abuse Issues

6502 Nursery Drive, Suite 100
Victoria, TX 77904
(361)575-0611
(800)421-8825

Child & Adolescent Development: Overview
Resources
Basic InformationMore InformationLatest News
Health Tip: Help Young Athletes Avoid MalnutritionShould More Kids Have Their Tonsils Out?Risk of Post-Op Infections Up in Overweight, Obese ChildrenParents Have Mixed Views on When to Keep Sick Kids Out of SchoolKids Born to Opioid-Addicted Moms Seem to Fare Poorly in SchoolPediatricians Offer Heads-Up for Preventing Soccer InjuriesHead for the Hills With Sled Safety in MindKids' Use of Artificial Sweeteners Spiked in Recent YearsHow to Spot a Common, Potentially Dangerous, Childhood IllnessDespite Pledges, No Improvement in Chain Restaurant Kids' Menus: StudyKids' Care May Suffer When Parents Clash With Medical StaffPoverty's Impact on a Child's Mental HealthAre Heartburn Meds During Pregnancy Linked to Asthma in Kids?Special Diet May Be Boon for Kids With Crohn's, ColitisKids' Asthma Flareups Fall Off After No-Smoking LawsExercise: An Antidote for Behavioral Issues in Students?Kids With Concussion Need Vision Check Before Return to SchoolHow to Keep Your Kids Cozy and Safe by the FiresideFor Kids With Kidney Disease, Race May Play Role in OutcomesDisabled Children Face Bullying Throughout School YearsHealth Tip: Watch Salt in Kids' DietsKids Landing in ERs After Drinking Parents' E-Cig Nicotine LiquidKids' Restaurant Meals Need Slimming Down: NutritionistsHealth Care Spending for U.S. Kids Jumped 56 Percent in Less Than 20 YearsHealth Tip: When a Child Is SickHealth Tip: Getting Your Child VaccinatedMumps Cases Hit 10-Year High in U.S.Give Kids a Safe, Stress-Free HolidayRest May Not Be Best for Kids After ConcussionSome Kids' Genes Might Make Food Ads More TemptingThe Impact of Child Abuse Can Last a LifetimeHealth Tip: If Your Child is CyberbulliedChild Abuse Cases in Army Families May Be Under-ReportedEmergency Surgery Riskier for Kids in Poorer CountriesHealth Tip: Help Kids Develop Healthy AmbitionMice May Be Key to Kids' Asthma Attacks at SchoolPCPs Order More Food Allergen Panels Than AllergistsNIAAA Two-Question Alcohol Screen Valid in Pediatric ERsHealth Tip: Build Your Child's Healthy PlateRSNA: Children Can Sustain Major Chest Injuries From ATV CrashesPediatricians Can Help When Parents Divorce: ReportMartial Arts Can Be Hazardous to KidsU.S. Kids Are Eating Healthier Now, But . . .Keep Kids in Mind When Politics Intrude at Thanksgiving'Enthusiastic' Dads May Mean Less Troubled Kids: StudyMore U.S. Kids Getting Drug-Resistant InfectionsPhysical Punishment of Children Declining in the United StatesStressed Childhood Might Raise Risk for High Blood Pressure LaterHealth Tip: Encourage Kids to Choose Good FriendsDoctors Use iPads to Treat 'Lazy Eye,' With Mixed Results
Questions and AnswersLinks
Related Topics

ADHD: Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder
Childhood Mental Disorders and Illnesses
Child Development & Parenting: Infants (0-2)
Child Development & Parenting: Early (3-7)

Kids' Care May Suffer When Parents Clash With Medical Staff

HealthDay News
by By Dennis Thompson
HealthDay Reporter
Updated: Jan 10th 2017

new article illustration

TUESDAY, Jan. 10, 2017 (HealthDay News) -- Rude parents can rattle medical staff enough to compromise the quality of care their critically ill child receives, a new study suggests.

Medical teams in a neonatal intensive care unit made worse decisions during simulated emergency scenarios if they had been treated rudely by an actress playing the role of an angry family member, the researchers found.

Exposure to rudeness helped explain about 40 percent of the variance in good medical decision-making between different teams in the study, said co-author Amir Erez. He is a professor with the University of Florida Warrington College of Business.

"There is a lot of concern about medical errors, but the medical field is not paying attention at all to the effect that social interactions can have on performance," Erez said. "They need to pay attention to this, because this could potentially save lives."

But, the researchers also found that doctors and nurses could "inoculate" themselves against potential rudeness by taking part in computer training that decreased their emotional sensitivity, Erez said.

In the study, four medical teams at an Israeli teaching hospital had to perform a full day's worth of five emergency scenarios.

Three of the teams started their day confronted by a "mother" who accused them of misdiagnosing her child. The fourth team served as a "control" group, and was not exposed to rudeness.

The actress told the teams, "I knew we should have gone to a better hospital where they don't practice Third World medicine!" and threatened to move the child to another hospital.

One team received no preparation for this encounter. But, the second team took part in a 20-minute computer game beforehand that exposed them to angry and happy faces, providing feedback that made them less sensitive to hostile emotions.

The members of the third team were asked to write a narrative about the rude event after it had occurred, to possibly diminish any lasting effect it might have on them.

Earlier studies have shown that rudeness from an authority figure can affect a medical team's performance, and this study revealed that rudeness from a parent can also cause doctors and nurses to make poor decisions, Erez said.

However, the computerized training beforehand erased this effect, by subconsciously raising the team's tolerance for negative emotions, he added.

"When we raised the threshold of people's sensitivity to anger, they didn't perform less well than the control group," Erez said.

Writing a narrative about the rude event had no benefit on performance, possibly because the exercise affected participants on a conscious rather than subconscious level, Erez suggested.

The study was published online Jan. 10 in the journal Pediatrics.

These findings show that doctors and nurses are human beings vulnerable to the effects of harsh emotions, said Dr. Brian Alverson, chairman of the American Academy of Pediatrics' section on hospital medicine.

"The reality is when we as humans are emotional, logical cognitive thought is a lot more difficult," said Alverson, an associate professor of pediatrics at Brown University in Providence, R.I. "When you're being emotionally attacked, it's harder to sit there and crunch the numbers quick."

Dr. Jessica Madden, a neonatologist with the Cleveland Clinic, added that the problem is made worse by the fact that intensive care unit teams often work in high-stress environments with colleagues they barely know.

"We're continually working with teams who come together who really haven't worked together before," Madden said of neonatal intensive care units. "They can literally be meeting for the first time to take care of a sick baby."

Training currently focuses on communication within the newly formed team, "but it doesn't factor in that with the patient-centered care model, we do have the parents with us," Madden said. "That's another layer of stress and worry that's going on as we try to focus."

However, Alverson is concerned that extrapolating the study findings -- for example, by applying them to other units not faced with split-second life-and-death decisions -- could lead doctors and administrators to shrug off real and lasting problems in each hospital's system.

"When families come in and act rude, the majority of the time it's because of something we've done. [For example,] we left them five hours in an ER waiting room without talking to them," Alverson said. "It's an opportunity lost where we could be looking at ourselves and asking how we can conduct our practice so people are happier."

More information

For more on doctor-patient relationships, visit the American Academy of Family Physicians.