24-Hour Crisis Hotline: (877)SAFEGBC or (877)723-3422 Mental Health & Substance Abuse Issues

6502 Nursery Drive, Suite 100
Victoria, TX 77904
(361)575-0611
(800)421-8825

Pain Management
Resources
Basic InformationLatest News
Upbeat Attitude May Be a Pain FighterWhy Do More and More Americans Use Medical Marijuana?Little Evidence Pain Creams Work'Mindfulness' Might Help Some Conquer Chronic PainMany Parents Conflicted About Opioids for Their Teens' PainOpioid Prescriptions Almost Twice as Likely for Rural vs. Urban AmericansOpioid Use in Pregnancy Tied to Severe Birth DefectsMore Americans Mixing Opioids With SedativesOpioids May Help Chronic Pain, But Not MuchPhysical Therapy Can Help You Avoid Opioids When Joint Pain StrikesNagging Low Back Pain? Try MindfulnessOpioids Plus Other Drugs a Deadly Mix for Heavy UsersHealth Tip: Manage Pain With OpioidsDoctors More Cautious Now When Prescribing Opioids to KidsEven Wisdom Tooth Removal May Spur Opioid AddictionOnly a Quarter of Opioid Painkillers Taken After Most SurgeriesOpioid Use May Sometimes Trigger A-FibFDA Approves Powerful New Opioid Despite CriticismsA New Challenger to Medical Marijuana?New Nerve Stimulation Technique Might Relieve Back PainDespite Opioid Crisis, Most Patients Want the Drugs for Post-Op PainFor Pain Relief, Why Not Try Drug-Free Alternatives?1 in 12 Americans Lives With Debilitating Chronic PainMindfulness May Be a Buffer Against PainCould a Placebo Pill Help Ease Your Back Pain?Chronic Pain May Drive Some to SuicideMonkey Trials Raise Hope for Non-Addictive Opioid AlternativeGovernment Rules Aimed at Curbing Opioid Prescriptions May Have BackfiredAs Opioid Epidemic Rages, Painkiller Prescriptions Don't DropMost Seniors Uninformed on Opioid UseSprained Ankle? Opioid Rx More Likely in Some States Than OthersOpioids Before Joint Replacement Tied to Worse RecoveryCould Botox Cousin Combat the Opioid Epidemic?Where Are Opioid Painkillers Prescribed the Most?Anti-seizure Meds Won't Ease Low Back PainMedical Marijuana a Hit With SeniorsRisky Prescribing Boosts Opioid Death RiskPatients on Opioids OK With Lower DosesPatterns of Potential Misuse Help Assess Risk of Opioid OverdoseHospitals Should, and Could, Avoid IV Opioids: StudyOpioid Makers' Perks to Docs Tied to More PrescriptionsPsychological Therapies May Help Older Adults With Chronic PainStudy Finds 31 Percent Use No Opioids After SurgeryAddictive Opioids Still Overprescribed After Surgery: StudyDoctors Curbing First-Time Prescriptions for OpioidsFDA Recalls Kratom Products Due to Salmonella ThreatMillions Get Wrong Treatment for Back Pain: StudyManaging Pain With Fewer Opioids After Joint ReplacementDoctors Present Recs For and Against Acupuncture for PainOpioids Don't Top Non-Opioids for Pain-Related Function
Questions and AnswersLinks
Related Topics

Depression: Depression & Related Conditions
Medical Disorders
Mental Disorders

Opioids May Help Chronic Pain, But Not Much

HealthDay News
by By Amy Norton
HealthDay Reporter
Updated: Dec 18th 2018

new article illustration

TUESDAY, Dec. 18, 2018 (HealthDay News) -- Potentially addictive opioid painkillers are often prescribed for chronic pain, but they actually work only slightly better than placebo pills, a new review shows.

The analysis, of 96 clinical trials, found that on average, opioids made only a small difference for people with conditions like osteoarthritis, fibromyalgia and sciatica.

And the modest pain relief sometimes came at a cost of side effects like nausea, vomiting, constipation and drowsiness.

The researchers said the findings add to evidence that for most people with chronic pain, opioids should be a last resort, if they're prescribed at all.

"Opioids should not be a first-line therapy for chronic, non-cancer pain," said lead researcher Jason Busse, of the Institute for Pain Research and Care at McMaster University, in Canada.

Dr. Michael Ashburn, a pain medicine specialist at the University of Pennsylvania, in Philadelphia, agreed.

"This is confirmation of the limited role opioids play in treating chronic, non-cancer pain," Ashburn said.

Most of the daily news on opioids centers on the national epidemic of abuse and addiction -- to prescription opioids and illegal forms like heroin.

But Ashburn stressed that the risks go beyond addiction: Patients can suffer side effects even when they diligently take their medication as directed.

"Opioids really only provide modest longer-term effects," he said. "And taking them for longer periods significantly increases the risk of harm."

Ashburn co-wrote an editorial published with the review findings in the Dec. 18 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association.

There are already medical guidelines -- from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and other groups -- that discourage doctors from prescribing opioids for most cases of chronic pain.

The new findings support those recommendations, Busse said.

Prescription opioids include drugs like Vicodin, OxyContin, codeine and morphine. They are powerful analgesics, Busse noted -- and they can ease cancer-related pain or severe short-term pain after surgery or an injury.

"But chronic, non-cancer pain seems to be different," Busse said.

Across the trials his team analyzed, opioids worked better than placebo pills -- but not by much. Overall, Busse said, 12 percent more patients saw a "noticeable" difference in their pain after starting opioids, versus placebo pills.

The benefits were even smaller when it came to patients' physical functioning and sleep quality.

Chronic pain is complex and has different roots, Busse pointed out. But there was no evidence that opioids work well for any particular form, he said.

Some trials, according to Busse, included people with nerve-generated pain -- from conditions like sciatica or diabetes-related nerve damage. Others focused on "nociceptive" pain, a broad category that includes conditions like osteoarthritis or pain after a bone fracture or other injury. Some studies followed people with pain related to central nervous system "sensitization" -- like fibromyalgia.

Across the board, opioids were only a little better than placebo pills, on average.

So what are the alternatives?

Only a small number of trials tested opioids against an "active" treatment, Busse noted.

Overall, his team found, opioids were no better than non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) like ibuprofen. They were also roughly equal to antidepressants, anti-seizure drugs (which are sometimes used for nerve pain) and synthetic cannabinoids.

Since those alternatives are generally safer than opioids, Busse said, it makes sense to try them first.

But, he stressed, there are also non-drug options -- including physical therapy, exercise, acupuncture and cognitive behavioral therapy.

None of those approaches were tested in these trials, but other studies have suggested they can help with chronic pain, Busse said.

In the "real world," Ashburn said, patients often need a combination of therapies. He added that treatment guidelines "clearly state" that even if opioids are prescribed, they should be used in combination with other treatments.

Ashburn stressed another point: Any opioid prescription should be considered a "trial" -- and if the drug does not help, it should be discontinued.

But in practice, Ashburn noted, when an opioid isn't helping, doctors commonly increase the dose.

"We've got to get better at knowing when to stop these drugs," he said.

A recent study by the CDC found that 50 million U.S. adults reported chronic pain -- defined as pain on most days for the past six months. That translates to 20 percent of the adult population.

More information

The U.S. National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health has more on managing chronic pain.