24-Hour Crisis Hotline: (877)SAFEGBC or (877)723-3422 Mental Health & Substance Abuse Issues

6502 Nursery Drive, Suite 100
Victoria, TX 77904
Fax: (361)578-5500

Medical Disorders
Basic InformationLookupsLatest News
AHA News: Quitting Smoking Could Lead to Major Changes in Gut BacteriaHealth Tip: Do's and Don'ts for Calling 911Experimental Injection May Protect Against Peanut AllergyReblozyl Approved to Treat Anemia in Patients With Beta ThalassemiaAHA News: High Blood Pressure Common Among Black Young AdultsAHA News: Congenital Heart Disease Linked to Neighborhood Pollution, PovertySome Headway Made Against 'Superbugs,' but Threat Remains: CDCHealth Tip: A Well-Stocked First-Aid KitLung Cancer Report Delivers Good, Bad NewsAHA News: Millions Unaware of Common Heart Attack SymptomsWant Extra Years of Life? Keep Blood Pressure Tightly ControlledTestosterone Supplements Double Men's Odds for Blood Clots: StudyHealth Tip: Treating Post-Nasal DripOpioids Won't Help Arthritis Patients Long-Term: StudyCommon Muscle Relaxant Could Pose Mental Dangers for SeniorsKratom May Cause Liver Damage: StudySupplements Don't Prevent Kidney Disease in Type 2 DiabeticsNew Tool Predicts Odds of Kidney DiseaseVitamin E Acetate Is Leading Suspect in Vaping-Linked Lung Illnesses: CDCVaping-Linked Lung Illnesses Top 2,000, CDC SaysAHA News: Stroke Death Rate Increasing for Middle-Aged AmericansRural Americans Dying More From Preventable Causes Than City DwellersWhy Hand-Washing Beats Hand SanitizersSleepless Nights Could Raise Heart RisksScreening Truckers for Sleep Apnea Cuts Health Insurance CostsDo You Take Biotin Supplements? They Could Affect Your Medical TestsAHA News: Heart Disease Down Over A Generation Among American IndiansRisks Mount for Lonely Hearts After Cardiac SurgeryDaylight Saving Time Bad for Health, Experts ClaimHealth Tip: Prevent BloatingCould a Blood Test for Breast Cancer Become a Reality?One Dead, 8 Hospitalized in Salmonella Outbreak Tied to Ground BeefMost Americans Fear Cancer, but Feel Powerless to Prevent It: SurveyFewer Opioids After Eye Surgery Don't Mean More Post-Op PainDrug Trio Could Give Patients With Cystic Fibrosis a New OptionCould Tissue-Sealing Tape One Day Replace Stitches?Deep Sleep May 'Rinse' Day's Toxins From BrainClose to 1,900 Cases of Vaping-Linked Lung Illness, CDC SaysMeasles Leaves People More Vulnerable to Future InfectionsHealth Tip: Nausea After EatingSooner Is Usually Better for Gallbladder SurgeryProtect Your Heart Through the Holiday SeasonReport Finds Americans' Health Is FlaggingAHA News: Retina Changes Offer Glimpse Into Body's Heart HealthWildfire Smoke Threatens Health for Miles AroundHealth Tip: Hand Swelling During ExerciseToo Many Seniors Back in Hospital for Infections Treated During First StayHealth Tip: Cold, Flu or Allergy?Health Tip: What Your Urine Color May MeanNew Database Shows 'Rare' Diseases Are Not So Rare Worldwide
Questions and AnswersLinks
Related Topics


Is Partial Hip Replacement Often the Better Option?

HealthDay News
by By Elizabeth Heubeck
HealthDay Reporter
Updated: Oct 3rd 2019

new article illustration

THURSDAY, Oct. 3, 2019 (HealthDay News) -- In recent years, the number of U.S. adults getting total hip replacements -- meaning both a new ball and joint socket -- following a hip fracture has soared to an estimated 500,000 annually.

That's nearly three times the rate at which these adults undergo a partial hip replacement, which only replaces the ball of the hip joint.

But a new Canadian study that compared the short-term outcomes of both surgeries showed somewhat surprising conclusions.

"What we now know is that within two years of having either a total or partial hip replacement, there's no difference, and possibly more harm, with total replacements," said lead author Dr. Mohit Bhandari, academic head of orthopedic surgery at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario.

The global study randomly assigned an estimated 1,500 patients -- all of whom were 50 or older with a hip fracture but able to walk independently -- to receive either a total or partial hip replacement.

Researchers wanted to learn, first and foremost, which group would be more likely to need a secondary hip procedure within two years of follow-up. They also analyzed differences between the two groups with regard to function and quality of life, as well as the development of serious adverse effects.

Most differences proved negligible. About 8% of patients in both groups needed to undergo a second hip procedure within 24 months of follow-up. Patients who received a total hip replacement reported slightly better function, less pain and stiffness than those with the partial hip replacement. But the improvements weren't enough to be clinically significant.

The difference in serious complications between the two groups perhaps came as the biggest surprise. Serious complications occurred in 42% of patients with a total hip replacement, compared to 37% among those with a partial hip replacement.

Bhandari suggested that the adverse effects suffered by either group may not have been a direct result of surgery, but added that any time you undergo a more complex surgery that takes longer, your risk of complications is likely to increase.

The findings were published recently in the New England Journal of Medicine.

A quick glance at the findings suggests that partial hip replacement is the way to go. But experts urge consumers not to jump to this conclusion.

"The study only looks at outcomes two years out," said Dr. Claudette Lajam, spokesperson for the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Many patients who opt for partial hip replacement, she said, end up returning to their surgeon later for additional surgery.

Here's one of the main reasons why. "A metal ball sitting in a native socket doesn't feel good after a while," explained Lajam, an associate professor of orthopedic surgery at the NYU Langone Orthopedic Hospital and Center for Musculoskeletal Care in New York City. After time, the natural cartilage of the individual's socket wears down as it moves against the artificial surface of the "metal ball" that is surgically implanted during a partial hip replacement.

Cost is generally not a deciding factor in which surgery to get, either. Most insurance plans, including Medicare and Medicaid, cover hip replacement surgery and associated costs. But a patient's age and anticipated remaining life span can and should play a pivotal role in the decision.

Bhandari explains: "Someone who's 51 may believe strongly they don't mind the potential of earlier risk for longer-term gain. But patients who are 90 may want to see less risk with similar earlier benefits."

While the study does provide new insights into some of the likely short-term outcome differences between partial and total hip replacements, it's unlikely to serve as a game-changer among candidates for hip surgery.

"It's a very individualized decision," Bhandari observed. "No patient with a hip fracture will fall under a blanket guideline."

More information

Visit the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons for more on hip replacement surgery.